
We fell in love as teenagers. For two years, she was part of the future I imagined. I thought we were good together. We made plans and talked about what might come next, the way young people do when love feels like forever.
Then she ended it. I remember what she said: “I can do better.”
It was like a kick to the chest. “Better?”
I couldn’t breathe, much less accept who was doing the kicking. The shock knocked my very soul to the ground. I couldn’t think straight. I couldn’t say how I was feeling. Nothing made sense. Everything was just wrong. I barely functioned at all.
At the time, those words hurt more than I could explain. The end arrived without warning. I couldn’t make sense of how someone so close to me could leave in a way that felt so final. I was young, but the hurt wasn’t small just because I was young. I carried it.
In a way, I still carry it today, forty years later.
Life moved on, as it does. We built separate lives. We didn’t talk.
Eventually, the old relationship became something I could remember without living inside it every day. I didn’t forget her, exactly. I learned to put the memory somewhere it wouldn’t keep tormenting me.
Then, decades later, she got in touch.
Her partner of seventeen years had died. She had lived through his illness and the long approach of his death. Before he was gone, they had talked about the life she would have afterwards without him. I understood that she didn’t want to face that life alone. She told him that there was this guy before him, someone she had loved very much.
Somehow, after all those years, she and I were back in contact.
She asked to meet for coffee. We had not spoken in a long time. Now she wanted to know what had happened to me. I sat across from someone I had once loved and tried to take in the distance between the girl I remembered and the woman in front of me.

It is strange how quickly the past can become present again. My mind was instantly taken back to the good times and the moment it ended.
After a year or so, I wasn’t thinking about us every day. I wasn’t waiting for her to return anymore. But seeing her in the flesh stirred something I thought had settled. The old closeness seemed to hover between us, along with the old injury. I could hear the words she had said when she left, even as I listened to what she was telling me now.
Some of that history later became part of the emotional material behind my SEETHINGS trilogy. But the coffee between us was not a scene I had written; it was a real choice, with no neat ending.
She regretted how things had ended. That mattered to me. I won’t pretend it didn’t. Some part of me wanted to hear that I was more than what she made me out to be. I wanted to believe that the years had changed us enough for another beginning to be possible.
That hope was real.
My doubt that it couldn’t happen was just as real.
We were not naive teenagers sitting together with our lives still ahead of us. We had lived through marriages, losses, choices and years the other person hadn’t witnessed. There was no way to step back into the relationship we remembered. Even if the feeling was still there, the people who had made that relationship were gone, changed by everything that had happened since.
I also couldn’t ignore the circumstances that had brought us together again. Claire (not real name) was grieving someone she had spent seventeen years with. I sensed how easily an old love could start to feel like a safe place to land when the current love died. I didn’t want to reduce her grief or loneliness, but I couldn’t pretend those things had nothing to do with the moment either.
That left me in an uncomfortable place. I wanted to be open to what might be between us. I wanted to know whether we might have something worth trying. At the same time, I was afraid we might be asking our teenage memories to do more than they could. The past could make us feel close quickly, but it couldn’t tell us whether we would fit together now.
I kept coming back to the way we had ended.
“I can do better.”
I didn’t want to punish her for words spoken decades earlier. People change. I had changed too. But forgiveness and trust aren’t the same thing, and wanting someone back isn’t the same as believing a relationship can work. I could still care about her and wonder whether we were making a mistake by looking backward for an answer.
My experience kept reciting this line: “If it didn’t work then, why would I think it would now?”
There was no clean way to weigh it. The part of me that wanted this to work wasn’t foolish. It remembered the happiness we had. It could see the possibility of two people meeting again after years apart and finding that something between them had survived.
The part that doubted it wasn’t cruel either. It remembered how much that first ending had cost me. It knew a second chance wouldn’t erase the first goodbye, and that love alone couldn’t guarantee we would be right for each other now.
We sipped our coffee, and I listened intently.
For a while, I had imagined that if an old love came back, I would know what to do. I didn’t. I wanted to say yes to the history, and I wanted to protect myself from repeating it. I wanted to believe the years had made a difference, but I could also see that they had made us strangers in important ways.
In the end, letting her go felt less like winning an argument and more like accepting destiny.
I could believe it was for the best and still feel sad. I could understand why we couldn’t return to what we had been without being glad that we couldn’t.
The first goodbye took away the future I had imagined as a young man. The second asked me to put that future down. I let it go because it felt like the kinder, safer choice. I didn’t walk away with satisfaction. I walked away knowing that something can matter deeply and still not be something you can make work.
–Michael (Dark Fiction. Author of SEETHINGS (the first book), free for a limited time)
Download eBook Now or Get Paperback Here
SEETHINGS II follows the return of the Storm Killer as a body on a secluded beach in Moreton Bay, igniting fear and denial. While police dismiss the link, the media doesn’t. Mitchell Felding forms a dangerous bond with a man who understands his darkest impulses. When Natasha enters his life, carrying love letters from her murdered mother, intimacy deepens, and truth closes in. Some futures are inherited. Some have escaped.
SEETHINGS (first in the series) is downloadable and free for a limited time here.

Discover more from Michael Forman – Author of Dark Fiction & Drama
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.