What Makes a Black-and-White Photo True? The Modern Photographer’s Blind Spot.

You’d think the answer is simple. A true black-and-white image contains no colour, only black, white and the tones of grey between them. We see black-and-white photographs every day, but many aren’t truly black and white.

It’s hard to find a proper black-and-white photo print these days. I see plenty of close monochrome examples but few prints without a colour cast. Almost every image is viewed on or in a colour medium, and keeping those other colours out of the mix is nearly impossible. Even the screen you’re viewing this page on may be adding a hue your eyes find hard to recognise.

My technical editor, Lyn Hall, was proofing my novel when he came across black-and-white photography in its text. He knew photography well, but was fascinated by something he’d never read before: the difference between a genuinely black-and-white print and one that only looks close. He too had developed photos in a home darkroom when he was a young man. With digital photography, the process is entirely different.

The days of darkrooms, silver nitrate, film and photographic paper have largely gone. Digital devices now synthesise blacks and whites using CMYK printing inks and RGB screens. That’s a lot of other colours sitting right beside the blacks that go on a white sheet of paper. My own journey from black-and-white film to digital photography followed that change, while the move from fixer to Photoshop altered the work of making a monochrome image.

Without careful calibration, a whisker of cyan can tint the blacks and make a photo feel cooler (or warmer with yellow). A little red on a display screen can make it look warmer than it should (or cooler with blue).

One of my characters, a professional photographer, has a conversation with another professional photographer: he remarks that not all black-and-white photos are truly black-and-white. Some are close, but most aren’t. The two photographers are part of the wider cast of characters in SEETHINGS.

This discussion builds on an earlier one, as Maxine Sewell calls Mitchell to solve another problem with her camera. She’s been taking ‘fuzzy-looking’ photos.

She calls too frequently. Her interest in him has grown since she discovered his marriage is on the rocks. Mitchell isn’t interested and finds ways to deter her advances.

After a brief discussion about using auto-focus for moving targets, Mitchell suggests she switch to manual focus to get the result she wants. But he discovers Maxine doesn’t know how. It’s a shocking revelation. How can a professional photographer not know how to focus a camera?

To save face, Maxine quickly switches the conversation. She talks about her black-and-white photography. She says her clients love her work and believe it’s good enough to win awards. But photography can reveal more than its maker intends; I explore that idea in Photography: A Confession Beyond the Lens.

Mitchell says the photos she showed him in her studio a week ago weren’t black and white at all. They had tones of magenta and green, and one was blue-and-white. He says her B+W prints were printed on colour paper, which introduces a hue. It’s not apparent in a single print. Put a true black-and-white photograph beside it, and the difference is unmistakable.

When Black and White isn’t Black and White

Maxine laughs and denies that her photo is “blue-and-white”.

Mitchell asks her to get a packet of her latest prints and spread them apart like playing cards, so each corner can be seen beside the next.

“What do you see?” he asks.

There’s an eerie silence.

Clearly, Maxine notices the differences. In all these years, she never recognised them. Every professional photographer she’d shown her work to would have known, but none said a thing.

She gets flustered, confused and angry. She uses some colourful language across the line, shouts and suddenly ends the call.

She calls him back, shouts more obscenities and hangs up again. She had the last word, a second time.

When I wrote Maxine Sewell into my novel, I had a real-life photographer in mind. She, too, would hang up when she didn’t hear people singing her praises, then call again to drive her point home. Life becomes art. The camera and photography also shape the story in SEETHINGS.

Another irony lies in the original call. Photography was an excuse. The contact had an ulterior motive and wanted more than a discussion about pictures and cameras. This is the kind of dark psychological fiction and moral ambiguity that interests me: what people say, what they want, and what they reveal without meaning to.

Mitchell wouldn’t take the bait, which infuriated her. Identifying her shortcomings behind the lens made it worse. When he showed up at a business party with someone else on his arm, she almost exploded. The only thing holding her back was sobriety.

With a full bottle of wine in front of her, that is sure to change.

(You’re wondering if the real-life person has read this in the book. I sure hope so.)

More in my novel SEETHINGS: A Psychological Thriller Trilogy About the Darkness Hiding in Plain Sight. The book is also available through SEETHINGS. – Michael

P.S. RIP Lyn Hall passed before the novel was published, but kept his thirst for knowledge alive until the end.

SEETHINGS promises a gripping psychological thriller that blends murder, passion, and secrets of a sexless marriage. Forman’s vivid prose draws readers into a world where lightning illuminates the skies and hidden truths. As the storm clouds gather, Mitchell’s journey promises to unravel more than just the mystery of the murders.

Download eBook Here Now (Free, Limited Time)


Discover more from Michael Forman – Author of Dark Fiction & Drama

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Hi. Welcome to the pit.

Scroll to Top