Encountering The Mysterious “Blackout” in Dark Fiction

Missing passages of time stir something deep inside us. Losing ourselves can be fascinating and frightening. A blackout can happen to anyone, at any time. It could even happen to me or you.

When we read about someone else’s blackout, we want to know why and how it happened. Was it too much drink, a strange drug, a nasty bump on the head, a medical episode, a traumatic experience, or something else that caused their memory to skip and lose time? Fear can also be involved; fear-related blackouts offer another possibility.

It’s awful to wake up and find we’re not where we’re supposed to be. Strangers look at us strangely. The place smells foreign. The sounds are totally unfamiliar. Everything appears at a weird angle. Our shoes are missing. The clock shows a different time.

Was it a self-inflicted blackout, or did someone else cause it?

Well-read fiction readers will go beyond those well-deserved feelings and look for answers about why the author brought the blackout into the story in the first place. They’ll suspect something important is going on, but suspicion isn’t enough to solve a mystery—and they know good authors will write twists to keep readers on their toes.

Fiction is a funny thing. It can take us anywhere. We can have our feet firmly planted on a sunny island in the Caribbean one second, then find ourselves on Planet Zolta the next. If a character doesn’t know how they got to Planet Zolta, we have a mysterious blackout in place and ready to tell a wonderful tale.

The author knows that such a gap can transport the story, the character and the reader to another time and place in a snap. In a story about interplanetary space travel, we can accept blackouts easily, because we’ll accept being on Planet Zolta shortly afterwards.

Science fiction is popular, but the same storytelling rules apply to every genre, including dark adult fiction. Some readers expect unsettling material to follow; disturbing fiction has its own audience and purpose.

Earthbound characters with a sense of contemporary realism experience their blackouts, and the reader gets enough detail to follow them through the transition and land them on the other side of the plot. The trick in my fiction is to make that transition feel scarily real—as though you or I could be dropped into the scene and face the drama ourselves. It’s no longer a fantastical trip to another galaxy. It’s a moral dilemma we could face today. Do we take the right fork in the road ahead, or the left?

That gets us thinking about how we’d deal with a certain moment. It becomes personal. Some readers are drawn to stories that make them sit with discomfort; the attraction to misery literature is part of that darker pull.

Gaps in a character’s memory also force readers to make assumptions. Sometimes, it’s at the exact moment an assumption tricks us. In dark fiction, that’s when the story gets comfortably uncomfortable. Readers are also drawn to the psychological appeal of dark fiction: the chance to explore fear, emotion and moral uncertainty within a story.

Sometimes we start a story with a blackout and then work backwards.

There’s an ornate knife.

A shaky hand holds it.

A warm body still twitches on the floor.

A protagonist breathes heavily, glaring at the knife at the end of their fingers. He looks past it to the body below, the blood and the floor, not knowing why he’s seeing what he sees. It isn’t his home. He’s never been there. He doesn’t recognise the deceased. The knife isn’t his.

His mind swirls uncontrollably.

He slowly stands and catches a glimpse of something in a mirror across the room. The face staring back is familiar, but he isn’t wearing his own clothes. He’s never owned a suit. He doesn’t even know how to tie a tie.

None of it makes sense—his heart races.

His legs go soft like jelly. He wants to fall to the floor. As he steadies himself, images pop into his mind.

The last thing he remembered was posing a beautiful orange monarch butterfly on a daisy for a still-life photograph in his basement studio. It was the most perfect specimen. Its legs were purposely shaped for genuine authenticity. The wings showed no signs of being manhandled. He was the best at posing insects in natural settings.

He knew how to handle dead insects without leaving marks on their fragile bodies and bring them to life in front of a lens. No one in his photography club ever knew quite how he did it. They never saw his method. They don’t know he has a basement.

Okay, so we know a few things about this protagonist:

He’s male, a bug guy and something of a photographer. He doesn’t wear suits. The last paragraph or two suggests some degree of meticulousness in his work or hobby. People recognise his special talents. There’s a tenuous connection to death between butterflies and the scene that started this journey.

The basement is potentially creepy, but it could also be a red herring meant to play on our assumptions about people who play with dead things in basements. Clichés make us believe one thing about our protagonist when we should be considering another. That tension between the heroic and the monstrous is explored in Writing Tips: Villains, Heroes, and the Space Between.

We know he was in one place doing one thing, then found himself somewhere else doing something totally different. The worlds oppose each other, yet collide. Why?

We don’t know anything about the victim. Was it an adult or a child? Why didn’t we get more information? And was it a room in a home, a hotel, an office, a hospital or somewhere else?

Once again, we make leaps without being forced to.

An adult male protagonist may lead us to assume the victim is also male. Similarly, if he’s the one holding a knife over a body, he’s probably a killer. Too many pathways to choose from, too little direction to choose one to walk along.

And then there’s the blackout itself, the reason this post exists. What makes a person go from posing butterflies for a basement still-life photograph to holding a bloody knife over a corpse in a foreign room, wearing unfamiliar clothes and not knowing what happened before it? Stories can explore the pressures that push a character to a breaking point, including psychological triggers.

Many things cause blackouts.

A toxic drug will do it.

A violent clunk to the head is a popular choice.

But what if the writer doesn’t want to use either method? After all, they are obvious ways to erase swathes of information without explaining why or how it happened. We accept it and quickly move on to the next part of the story.

Situational dissociation is a different form of blacking out. Here, the sufferer is awake, alert and active. They participate in life and act like normal people doing normal things. There are few indicators to denote a change in their personality. The effects can be difficult to recognise.

The condition is triggered by something.

When the right environmental and psychological conditions are met, a switch flicks on inside the brain. The person becomes someone else for a time, then returns to themselves later.

It’s a challenging plot type to construct because it requires the character to participate in two storylines, each unknown to the other. It’s also important to keep the reader out of the loop long enough for a big reveal to land at just the right time.

Can someone like you and me live one life and not know about a temporary other?

We are about to find out.

This is the kind of morally uncertain storytelling I explore in my Dungeon of Dark Fiction.

–Michael (Dark Fiction. Author of SEETHINGS (the first book), free for a limited time)

SEETHINGS promises a gripping psychological thriller that blends murder, passion, and secrets of a sexless marriage. Forman’s vivid prose draws readers into a world where lightning illuminates the skies and hidden truths. As the storm clouds gather, Mitchell’s journey promises to unravel more than just the mystery of the murders.

Download eBook Here Now (Free, Limited Time)


Discover more from Michael Forman – Author of Dark Fiction & Drama

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Hi. Welcome to the pit.

Scroll to Top